Making purchases at Amazon.com and other website funds this website by generating revenue. Any help is appreciated and supports both me and content like this.
Best Chef Pan aka Saucier
The Best Chef Pan has a rounded corner, comfortable handle and wide rim. It is truly one of the most versatile pan in the market. However, most people dont even know what it is. A Chef pan or Saucier is a blend between a frying pan and a sauce pan. While its primary task is to make sauce. If you get the right one, you should be able to cook just about anything in this pan. When buying a Chef Pan, there are various things you should look for. Things like material, construction and shape are all very important. This article will list all the variables you should check and hopefully help you get the right one.
What to Look for in a Chef Pan aka Saucier
Shape
The shape of the Saucier is one of the most important thing. Its primary task is to make sauces. As such, the traditional sauce pan with sharp corners is not ideal. You want a soft gradual edge that rises. This means that when you whisk sauces, the spatula or whisk will glide over it. Sharp corner means that food will get trapped. The consistency will be slightly off and worse, burned.
These days most pots are manufactured with a hydraulic press. Making a smooth gradual interior cost money. It is much cheaper to just stamp and go. Usually only the higher end manufacturer like Le Creuset, All Clad and Matfer Bourgeat will do this.
Metal and Thickness
The metal and thickness of the pan plays an important role. Certain metal like copper are extremely responsive. Very important when making sauces. If you accidentally overheat the pan, being able to stop cooking can save the sauce. However, if you have it too thick, that responsiveness is gone. Models like the copper core series from All Clad are a great choice. It uses a copper core for maximum responsiveness.
Stainless Steel and Fully Cladded Pan are a good alternative. However, their responsiveness is not as great. You want something thats not too thick and not too thin. The one made by Le Creuset is a fine example of that.
Handle
Comfort and ergonomic is important as well. To use a saucier, you will constantly be moving the pan around. Having something that will cause pan and discomfort will make you hate the pan.
With that being said. I can think of very few saucier that has a combination of all these traits. The one exception is the saucier made by All Clad with the Thomas Keller handle. Unfortunately, those are not as readily available.
Nonstick Coating
Usually you do not have to worry about food sticking. After you brown the food, you can soak the food in water. Food will release naturally and you can scrape any stuck on bits. Its not important to have a nonstick coating. I would also argue that the stainless steel lining is better and more durable. It wont degrade and break down like teflon pan. You need to replace those in one or two years. Where as the stainless one will pretty much last forever.
Le Creuset Saucier Pan (Best Overall)
Categories | Le Creuset 3.5 qt Saucier |
---|---|
Performance | Excellent |
Country of Manufacturer | Portugal |
Oven Safe Temperature | 500 Degree Fahrenheit |
Compatibility | Gas, Electric, Halogen, Glass Top, Induction |
Capacity | 3.5 qt |
Material | Tri-Ply Stainless and Aluminum |
Shape | Le Creuset Saucier has a nice gradient interior. This allows for easy whisking and stirring. The diameter is wide giving you ample room to sear food. This wide rim also means that it has a larger surface area. This helps promotes evaporation and makes it easier to stir food. |
Handle | The handle stainless steel and will keep cool to the touch. It is wide with a soft taper, giving it a ergonomic grip. The flat design also means that it wont rotate in your hand when you are pouring. It is also angled slightly to help with the overall balance. |
Thoughts | While the metal used is not as responsive as copper, the tri ply design is still a very responsive metal. The reason why its one of the best saucier is because of the shape. The large diameter and interior makes it one of the best saucier. If only it was made with copper… |
Reviewed Cookware | Le Creuset SSP6100-24 Tri-Ply Stainless Steel Saucier Pan with Lid and Helper Handle, 3.5-Quart |
All Clad Chef Pan
Categories | All Clad 2qt Saucier |
---|---|
Performance | Excellent |
Country of Manufacturer | USA |
Oven Safe Temperature | 600 Degree Fahrenheit |
Compatibility | Gas, Electric, Halogen, Glass Top, Induction |
Capacity | 2 qt |
Material | 5 Ply Copper Core |
Shape | Much like Le Creuset, the interior has a smooth gradual gradient. This makes whisking and stirring a breeze. However, the diameter is not as large which can get annoying sometimes. It feels like a barrier you must overcome. |
Handle | Unfortunately, this is where All Clad loses. Their handle is simply not comfortable. Overtime your hand will get fatigued and sore. The good thing about their design is that it helps you maintain a good grip. It also stays cool to the touch. |
Thoughts | Because of the thickness and copper used, it is one of the most responsive saucier out there. If you accidentally overheat the sauce all you need to do is turn down the heat. Other chef pan will continue burning and ruin your sauce. If only the handle was better, than it would be one of the best saucier out there. |
Reviewed Cookware | All-Clad 6212 SS Copper Core Stainless Steel Saucier Pan Cookware, 2-Quart, Copper |
Matfer Bourgeat Chef Pan
Categories | Matfer Bourgeat Saucier |
---|---|
Performance | Excellent |
Country of Manufacturer | France |
Oven Safe Temperature | Unspecified |
Compatibility | Gas, Electric, Halogen, Glass Top, Induction |
Capacity | 2 3/4 qt |
Material | Copper and Stainless Steel |
Shape | Matfer Bourgeat Saucier has a soft gradual interior like the others. The only issue is the rim is not as flared. This makes it restrictive when you stir. Instead of a back and forth motion, you will whisk in a circular fashion. While it will work, its not as effective. |
Handle | A traditional cast iron handle. It will get screaming hot but its comfortable and offers plenty of leverage. Overall, this is a heavy pan and tough handle like cast iron is necessary. |
Thoughts | Matfer Bourgeat saucier uses one of the best metal out there. The copper and stainless steel means you can get the best sear out of all the pans. The only issue is the small rim diameter and the handle. If the rim was larger and flared out, this would be a winning pan. As for the handle, I like the cast iron but I can see how a stainless steel one would be better. |
Reviewed Cookware | Matfer Bourgeat COPPER FLARED SAUTE PAN 9 1/2″ |
Best Chef Pan Thoughts
While there are many factor to consider, you should choose one that best suits your needs. Since I have all of these saucier, I dont really need to be picky. Unfortunately not one of these pans is the best in all category. If you think responsiveness is the most important, go with all clad. If you want straight heat and searing ability, buy matfer bourgeat. For the best balanced model, I would go for the Le Creuset. It has the biggest capacity the handle is comfortable and it strikes the right balanced of responsiveness and heft. If only they have a copper core.
I hope you like this Best Chef Pan article, If you would like to see more, please visit our Pots and Pans Review page.
Falk Copper Saucier Review - How does it compare to Matfer Bourgeat?
May 18, 2020 at 9:57 pm[…] to whisk. In my opinion, that is a defining feature of a good saucier. In fact, my article on the Best Saucier Pan list those saucier as some of the best in the […]
James
December 11, 2020 at 8:49 pmI think your last sentence you meant to say Le Crueset and not All Clad? It’s the only thing that makes sense.
“Unfortunately not one of these pans has a combination of all the important factor. If you think responsiveness is the most important, go with all clad. If you want straight heat and searing ability, buy the matfer bourgeat one. For the best balance of all three attribute, I would go for the All Clad one. It has the biggest capacity and the name Le Creuset will not disappoint.“
Curated Cook
December 11, 2020 at 9:03 pmYes that is correct. Thank you for letting me know. I will updated it.